Diner reviews of Colorado Mine Co Steakhouse
A diner from Atlanta
Aug 19, 2010
After waiting far too long, and being given the check for another party, we stood up to force the waitress to act. When I told her that the cummulative delays had put us far behind schedule and in a big hurry, she (Tiffany) stated, "The problems of the world are not mine." Becca, the alleged manager, was only interested in making excuses.
A diner from to be syracuse, NY
Mar 25, 2010
this used to be a great place to go to, however havent been back in a few years so when we got the chance we visited on monday. The place like the food was tired. only 3 tables had people at them when our food came it was bland, when we mentioned it nothing was done I felt like we got your money who cares. I'll never go back there again.
A diner from liverpool
May 14, 2009
I recently ate here with my family my waiter was spaced out seemed to be more interested in socializing with the waitresses he worked with than tending to our needs. The staff seemed poorly trained unprofessional and rude. The food was overcooked and the steak fatty.
A diner from Carthage, NY
Apr 15, 2009
Waitress was either very new or very distracted. It took over an hour an a half to complete our dining experience. My drink was refilled once during that time, and my daughters was never refilled (yes we did ask). Our food was prepared close to our request, but not as requested. We finally received the bread for the meal just after dessert arrived. After all this, the check took another 10 minutes to arrive and then she wouldn't pick it up for another 10 minutes. It took over 25 minutes to pay the bill. The service completely ruined what may have been an otherwise OK evening. Worst service in recent memory.
A diner from Orlando FL
Jan 23, 2009
Had a great meal at an acceptable price. Party of 7 was served later in the evening - only one other table was occupied. Service just a tad slow, but not unbearable. Filet mignon was very tasty and cooked just right. Prime rib was huge and done correctly. Love the bread! This was my second visit within 8 months - experience at first visit was also good. Go there and enjoy!
A diner from Syracuse NY
Jun 10, 2007
Horrible food for the most part. Prime rib was sickly looking and tasted gross. Tilapia had enough salt seasoning to last a sea voyage. Shrimp cocktail was excel and really was our "main" course. My wife and I left half the meat and fish on our plates.
A diner from Liverpool, NY
May 22, 2007
Food was different from what I normally eat (I didn't get the steak!) but it was excellent. Nice atmosphere, too.
A diner from Syracuse, NY
Aug 9, 2005
GREAT TIME WAS HAD BY ALL. The food was cooked exactly how we ordered it and the waitress even suggested a couple items we wouldn't normally have tried. The attention to detail was nice -- you don't always get that at other restaurants.
The waitress was great with my little girl. Nice kids menu & activities for the youngsters.
Overall, very satisfied! Keep up the good work.
A diner from Syracuse, NY
Sep 6, 2004
This is easily the worst place that I have ever ate at. We took oue out of town family here for steaks. We had all asked them to be cooked medium rare to well done. They came to us rarer than rare. They were more or less browned on one side flipped over and browned on the second side. We could not send them back as our waitress was no where to be seen. Refills on drinks didn;t happen either. The french fries we cold and greasy. When the waitress did finally show we told her about our less than half eaten steaks being way under cooked, She as if we wanted to speak to a manager who never showed. Our check was dropped off at our table in a hit and run type transaction for which once again she never came back for so I guess it was a good thing we had cash to pay for this worse than worse meal. My advice --- STAY AWAY!!!
A diner from Cambridge, ON
May 3, 2004
Excellent food, service, and value. Best Steak in the region. Try the huge sweet potatoes!
A diner from Syracuse, NY
Feb 9, 2004
MY BOYFRIEND AND I WERE DISSATISFIED WITH OUR COLORADO MINE CO SPECIAL BECAUSE OUR STEAK WAS VERY DRY. WE WERE VERY DISAPPOINTED BECAUSE WE HAD HEARD REALLY GREAT THINGS ABOUT THERE STEAK, BUT IT REALLY WASN'T THAT GREAT.
A diner from moravia, NY
Nov 19, 2002
unable to make reservations, but when you finally set (after 1 hour or more) the food is great and the waitress try to keep up their spirits even though most diners complaining of the wait and inability to make reservations-nothing on that respect has changed in past two years despite request to management!
A diner from Long Island, NY
Jun 4, 2002
Excellent place to dine. Service and food availability suffers when the place is crowded.Unprepared for a convention crowd.
A diner from Stittsville, ON
Dec 23, 2000
Always visit Colorado Mine Co when we are in Syracuse. Fantastic food and great atmosphere. Overall a great place!
Write a review
