Carmel Restaurant Guide
Mitchell's Fish Market
(4 ratings)
(317) 848-3474
14311 Cherry Tree Road, Carmel, IN 46033
Dining Specials
Agave Bar & Grill
July 16, 2008 @ 4:30 PM
a diner from Carmel, IN
We went to Mitchells and were extremely disapointed. When I opened my silverware, the forks had old food crusted to it. The server's name was J**** and she was the worst server I have ever had in my life. The food was cold and it all came out at the same time (appetizers, salad, dinner). I would not recommend this restaurant to my worst enemy!
January 27, 2008 @ 5:53 PM
a diner from Fishers, IN
Expensive for average food marketed as "fresh". One would hope so. Took forever to obtain a cocktail. French fries were lukewarm. Server was excellent when he finally showed up. This restaurant seems to be exploiting the expensive fish trend. I had a super cod fish fry for $12.95 at another place. Here it was $16.95.
Read More
Mitchell's Fish Market Reviews
50% Off Dining Certificates at these locations...
Avg Rating:
Number of Reviews: 4
July 16, 2008 @ 4:30 PM
a diner from Carmel, IN
We went to Mitchells and were extremely disapointed. When I opened my silverware, the forks had old food crusted to it. The server's name was J**** and she was the worst server I have ever had in my life. The food was cold and it all came out at the same time (appetizers, salad, dinner). I would not recommend this restaurant to my worst enemy!
January 27, 2008 @ 5:53 PM
a diner from Fishers, IN
Expensive for average food marketed as "fresh". One would hope so. Took forever to obtain a cocktail. French fries were lukewarm. Server was excellent when he finally showed up. This restaurant seems to be exploiting the expensive fish trend. I had a super cod fish fry for $12.95 at another place. Here it was $16.95.
December 28, 2007 @ 3:55 PM
a diner from Carmel, IN
We love Mitchell's. The food, servers, bar, etc is just perfect. A great place to eat!!!
December 28, 2006 @ 5:29 PM
a diner from Carmel, IN
We have gone to Mitchells approx. 5 times and every time we think we'll try the oyster bar and every time we are extremely disapointed. The main courses are wonderful - can't say enough about the quality of the seafood main courses but the raw oysters are absolutely terrible and we've tried them 5 times.
Mitchell's Fish Market Map
Recent Mitchell's Fish Market Reviews
July 16, 2008 @ 4:30 PM
a diner from Carmel, IN
We went to Mitchells and were extremely disapointed. When I opened my silverware, the forks had old food crusted to it. The server's name was J**** and she was the worst server I have ever had in my life. The food was cold and it all came out at the same time (appetizers, salad, dinner). I would not recommend this restaurant to my worst enemy!
January 27, 2008 @ 5:53 PM
a diner from Fishers, IN
Expensive for average food marketed as "fresh". One would hope so. Took forever to obtain a cocktail. French fries were lukewarm. Server was excellent when he finally showed up. This restaurant seems to be exploiting the expensive fish trend. I had a super cod fish fry for $12.95 at another place. Here it was $16.95.
