Dayton Restaurant Guide

Dayton steak house Restaurant Reviews

Displaying 1 - 20 of 24
Sort By: Latest Reviews | Rating | A-Z
simply the best
Old Hickory Bar-b-que on No. Main St. in Dayton is the best! You always get great value for your money. The portions are very good and the service is great! The steaks and ribs are a great buy compared to what you get at more expensive reaturants like the Oakwood Club. Also, the sea scallops are...
5 star(s)
(08/29/2010)
Some friends took me out for my birthday. They told me we were going to Old Hickory on Brown St.I said ok I never ate at that one, only ate at the one on Main. Well I really enjoyed myself and everything was just as they said exellent, even our waitor Billie, he was one of the nices young man I have...
Great experience. Always a great dinner. We love the Steak & Ribs !! Best in Dayton.
Absolutely the Best restaurant in Dayton. The staff is fantastic and the owners are always available to diners new and old. I love the shrimp coctails and Faye at the bar is the best of the best.
5 star(s)
(02/12/2010)
I hate to read bad reviews of this place, as our family loves it! I order the Roquefort burger every time and it's seriously the best burger i have ever had! We went today and everything was so fresh and hot...that I could barely eat my fries. Not a complaint---very fresh! I also had the salad with ...
This is the only place I will eat ribs.. and their cocktail sauce for shrimp is so good I buy jars to use at home. When I get home to Dayton this is the place I want to go, and if I am short on time I get carry out. Been eating here for years and when my mother turned 85 there was only one place she...
Have ate at the Old Hichory many many times over the years and the King Cut New York Strip is excellent. I would highly recommend trying this wonderful meal.
5 star(s)
(10/06/2009)
The Oakwood Club has been around forever. I lived in the Centerville area and my parents just always loved this establishment. I moved away to the Bellefontaine area and during the time of my birthday I am always wanting a good steak, what always comes to mind is "The Oakwood Club". The bar is a ver...
1 star(s)
(03/16/2009)
If possible I wouldn't give the Oakwood Club any stars. Our experience there was the second worst experience I have ever had at a restuarant. We made reservations for March 14, 2009 for a party of six. The reservations were made more than 4 days in advance. When we arrived at the restaurant we were ...
5 star(s)
(12/15/2008)
a wonderful home owned and family type place we love it and for ten years have always had a great meal experince
I was raised in Dayton and come back ther about 4 times a year for various reasons. These trips always include ribs from old hickory. To me, they are the best after sampling many others. I only eat ribs from Hickory now.
I have been eating barbecue here for years. It is the best I have had by far. The price is a little high. But the food is great.
I think this is one of the better places to have a great steak. The service is always great and never had a bad steak.
I have been going to this restaurant for as long as I can remember. As a kid I would go up on East Third street to watch the ribs turn on the long skewers. I now go to the one on Brown street as much as I can. The food is great and it has a nice homey feel to it. The staff is great there too.
5 star(s)
(11/12/2006)
Wonderful! Busy, exciting place to eat and enjoy the evening; food is outstanding and service is equally great;
5 star(s)
(04/01/2006)
This place is a diamond in the rough.Just moved here.We always had a favorite reataurant back home and now we have a new one and a new favorite waitress.Thanks to Amy we enjoyed great wine "Hangtime pinot noir" food "bone on filet and fresh Halibut" Amy was a hoot from the get go. She really made us...
5 star(s)
(09/12/2005)
I have been going to this restaurant for over 30 years and it still has the best ribs in Dayton. Friends who have retired to FL come here as soon as they get back to OH for the ribs and the great Shrimp cocktail. I never order ribs anywhere but here. Steaks are outstanding also. Service is excelle...
5 star(s)
(07/26/2005)
After all the years, The Hickory is still one of the best restaurants in Dayton.
How can you go wrong with this place? The BBQ chicken is outstanding and I've heard that the ribs are great as well. Not only that, but you get a lot of food for your money.